Mafia Games - Progress

Mafia Game & Rules

  Esequiel said:

Could you let us know Jonnas? Also are your sign ups closed?

My sign-ups will be closed a few days before I start the game. That is, when Tellyn's game seems to be halfway/to slow down.

I still have a few neat roles in mind, so including people in the last minute won't be bothersome.

Also, while organizing the "Animafia", I've come across the idea of Comic Book/Strip mafia. If Animafia becomes successful, that will be the next theme.

This could do with updating now that Mundi's DIY has finished.

Deleted all posts up to the request.

Thanks Mod And updated now.

If anyone spots a mistake let me know :P

I'm pretty sure the good guys won Mundi's mafia game.

I always thought that if ANY neutral won then it was the neutrals game?

Correct me if im wrong but i figure a Neutral has there own agenda so if they win.... they win.

The townies never got rid of the neutrals so they were runners up.

Hmm, I dunno, the townies win when "all the threats to the town are gone", not by getting rid of everyone but themselves. They often share a win condition with neutrals.

Not to mention Mundi put everyone as a winner. It might be worth looking in to. I'd say there are only runners up when somebody wins the game but the game continues (for example, when Zell won when someone else was killed).

I think that both Neutral and Town win the game :S

You must say "Neutral and Town" its unfair to Town to be a runner up

But surely having the neutrals win conditions the same as the towns (Or mafias) is just plain silly then? If thats the case they would just be Townies?

My understanding is that Neutals superscede everything i.e

Neutal wins when Mafia are gone - 1 neutral left 3 townies

Neutral is the overall winner.

Otherwise whats the point of having neutrals?

Some neutrals have other win conditions that could change or not necessarily fit in with what the Townie's want - but if they win, it doesn't mean the town have finished as runners up.

Well some of the neutrals could have been townies just as well, for example Coolness Bears. He was neutral with no power, but won when the town would win. Which just makes him a townie to me.

The town won in the last game.

I don't think there can be grounds to sticky this, sorry. Even though I take part in them, I have to appreciate that it's not a thread relevant to the forum majority. Rather, why don't people who take part just bookmark it?

Aye, I agree with that. Though it might be useful if we had a mafia sub forum or something :P

Understood Shorty

Updated as per everyones requests. Mundis game now Neutral/Town wins.

The town won that game. It's just that there were many "Neutrals" that would win when the town won.

Yeah, I don't understand it either, since that makes them townies as well.

Now, if they won when somebody else (Mafia or Town) won, then there would be reasons for being Neutral. But Vicar and CB were practically townies.

I agree, they were practically Townies... anyone with a win condition of winning when the townies do is basically a townie..... BUT its mundi's game and he says there neutrals so i make it a Neutral/Townie win and everyone gets a point.

I think Raining_Again deserves a point/win for her contribution to Mundi's mafia when Ell was on holiday.

  MoogleViper said:

I think Raining_Again deserves a point/win for her contribution to Mundi's mafia when Ell was on holiday.

hey i just said that in the other thread! :p

Done.

Maybe we should give out a few bonus points to people who contribute more etc?

I think I deserve a win in mafia game #5 after all that trouble.

  Shino said:

I think I deserve a win in mafia game #5 after all that trouble.

No you don't. Zell was clearly Neutral in that one.

You were a winner.

Both you and Zell were winners.

  Esequiel said:

Done.

 

Maybe we should give out a few bonus points to people who contribute more etc?

I think that beats the purpose of trying to win and takes a bit of the glory of winning.